Best Secondhand Shop - Pony - Best of New York Shopping 2012 -- New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Best Secondhand Shop

  • Pony

    69 Fifth Ave., nr. St. Marks Pl., Park Slope; 718-622-7669

    A refreshing contrast to the packed racks and messy piles at many thrift shops, the meticulously arranged resale shop almost makes you feel like you’re buying new. Clothing�all of which is laundered and steamed before it hits the racks�is grouped by color and helpfully tagged with the brand, the fabric, and a short description alongside the price. Though pristine vintage pieces are interspersed, the bulk of the inventory is current, stylish clothing: Like-new merchandise by Club Monaco�level chains typically goes for under $50, while A.P.C. cords and Marc Jacobs jeans are about $50, and dresses by Tracy Reese or Rag & Bone might be tagged at about $75.

From the