Eh, nah. That kind of monster would have clearly washed up on Fire Island.
*You didn’t see the picture of his balls? The Monster of Montauk, just like Princess Chunk, is all man, man.
Related: Investigating the Montauk Monster[NYM]
East Hampton Bureaucrats Deny Montauk Monster Is Beast From Hell [NYM]
Montauk Monster Mania! [NYM]
What Today’s Monster News Tells Us About New Yorkers [NYM]