The Knickerbocker

Profile

For hotel nerds and history buffs, the southeast corner of Broadway and 42nd Street should be hallowed ground: The Knickerbocker Hotel, opened here in 1906 by John Jacob Astor IV (who also owned the Waldorf-Astoria, and later died on the Titanic), was the birthplace of the martini, the original home of the famous Maxfield Parish mural now at the King Cole Bar, and a favorite of so many politicians, businessmen, and celebrities that it was nicknamed "the 42nd Street Country Club." Closed in 1921 and later converted to offices, the hotel has been reopened under its original name � though Astor and his crowd would hardly recognize it. Designed by noted firm Gabellini Sheppard to be a haven from the color and chaos of Times Square, the place is serene and friendly from the start, full of muted palettes and subtle retro touches. Past the knickerbocker-and-cap-wearing staffers, you'll find public spaces like the lobby-level Jake's cafe, the Charlie Palmer at the Knick restaurant (where USB-charger-equipped tables give new meaning to the term "power breakfast"), and the stunning St. Cloud rooftop, with a Waterford-crystal lounge, Nat Sherman cigar lounge, and "sky pods" perched over Times Square (a hot ticket for New Year's Eve). The 330 spacious, contemporary rooms and suites offer still more calm with double-paned windows, high-end bedding, and expanded amenities (like Tide To-Go pens, cuff links, and hair accessories). Perks include one-touch tablet room controls, cosmetics menus by Ted Gibson Beauty Bar, and room service by Charlie Palmer. The on-site gym offers workout equipment, a boxing pit, and on- and off-site fitness programs developed by former New York Knick Larry Johnson, while thoughtful amenities like strollers, toys, and car seats help make families comfortable. — Sandra Ramani

Pros
Central location; quiet and spacious rooms; upgraded amenities; standout dining and rooftop; family- and pet-friendly.

Cons
No spa.