2 years ago / 9:45 PM EDT

DeSantis said they “back the blue” in Florida. In Illinois, DeSantis took out ads on billboards offering $5,000 signing bonuses to police move to his state and serve.

2 years ago / 9:45 PM EDT

DeSantis again says Florida's at a 50-year crime low. As we reported last week, that's just an unverifiable number that law enforcement officials repeatedly warned was based on incomplete data.

2 years ago / 9:44 PM EDT

NBC News is watching the debate at Aase Haugen, a Christian retirement community in Decorah, Iowa, with seven caucusgoers.

Kent Shuchmann, 77.Alexander Tabet / NBC News

Kent Shuchmann, 77, voted for Trump twice but went into tonight’s debate leaning Haley. At the first commercial break, he says the only one who’s impressed him is Ramaswamy. He likes the 38-year-old businessman’s style.

“I’m impressed the way Ramaswamy fights. He’s there for battle, and he battles well.”

2 years ago / 9:44 PM EDT

DeSantis does look a lot more physically comfortable tonight compared to last time. The awkward smile, the strange volume modulation (recall the semi-shouted answer at the outset of the first debate): That’s all gone. It seems like he got some training and is a bit more at ease behind the lectern. 

2 years ago / 9:43 PM EDT

Chart: The candidates with the most attacks out of the gate

Scott targeted Biden and Ramaswamy in seven attacks in the first 30-some minutes of the debate. Follow along with the NBC News debate attack tracker.

2 years ago / 9:43 PM EDT

Christie’s pulling a “Donald Duck” line reminds me of the 2016 campaign when a Democratic staffer dressed up in a duck costume to mock Trump for refusing to release his taxes.

In 2016, Christie’s most famous debate moment was when he roasted Marco Rubio for repeating a canned line over and over. And yet, it really feels like some of his Trump lines tonight — including his “Donald Duck” bit — were rehearsed ahead of time.

2 years ago / 9:43 PM EDT
Ali Vitali

Seeing all of these candidate spouses sitting behind the moderators, it strikes me that Haley’s husband is not there because he’s serving overseas for the next year.

2 years ago / 9:43 PM EDT

Vivek vs. Pence again taking center stage

Headed into the night, there was a growing expectation that DeSantis and Haley would be a major focus, and likely spar with each other.

More than 30 minutes in, though, the attacks are once again flying between Ramaswamy and Pence, who came after Ramaswamy’s past debate performance during the first GOP debate in Milwaukee.

“Last debate he said we were all bought and paid for,” Pence said.

Ramaswamy did call everyone on stage “good people” in a departure from his past combative debate performance, but responded to Pence saying “these are good people tainted by a broken system.” 

2 years ago / 9:41 PM EDT
Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie speaks during the Republican presidential primary debate in Simi Valley, Calif., on Wednesday night.Mark J. Terrill / AP

Chris Christie takes another shot at Trump for not attending — and talks straight to camera to Trump. Gets some jeers for saying they will start calling Trump “Donald Duck” if he doesn’t start showing up.

2 years ago / 9:41 PM EDT

The first question after the break is on crime, a topic where Republican candidates are uniquely positioned to address the issue, according to our latest NBC News poll. Forty-six percent of registered voters said that the Republican Party is better at dealing with crime than the Democratic Party. Just 20% of voters said Democrats are better at dealing with the issue.