The 11 Very Best White Button-down Shirts for Women

Sizes: XXS–XXL | Fabric: Cotton | Design details: Point collar, dropped shoulders, big patch pockets | Price: $

When I reached out to stylish women for this story, Everlane was the brand mentioned the most — “For the price, you can’t do much better” was the general sentiment I heard — and out of all the button-downs I tried, Everlane’s Boxy Oxford is the closest to Ayr’s Deep End. It comes with big patch pockets (two instead of one), dropped shoulder seams, and a curved hem (with cutouts on the sides — as seen here). And while the fit is similar to Ayr’s, the main difference is that the Boxy Oxford is squarer in shape. I liked that about it; the Oxford is very “I borrowed this shirt from someone else’s closet.” It also looks just as nice buttoned up as it does unbuttoned (usually, button-downs only look good one way or the other, in my opinion). It’s a real steal at $88, making it an affordable alternative to our best-in-class button-down.

Other Everlane button-downs of note: the Relaxed Oxford and Way-Short. Bum-Cake Vintage owner Christiana Greene likes that the first is a little oversize. Blogger Kristina Zias agrees: “I wouldn’t say it’s the most ‘flattering’ shirt — I wear it unbuttoned.” Blogger Hailey Rizzo thinks the second is “cropped but not too cropped,” making it ideal for anyone hunting for a slightly shorter button-down.

Sizes: XS–4X (with petite and tall options) | Fabric: Cotton | Design details: Spread collar, patch pocket, curved hem | Price: $

Plus-size cuts have evolved over the years and become better fitting in the process. Content creator Nikki Apostolou — who is one of my go-to sources for plus-size fashion coverage — cites this button-down as one such example. She praises the boyfriend-style fit, which falls to the thighs rather than the top of the hips. And while it’s meant to be oversize, it’s not so oversize that you lose your shape entirely when it’s on. “If you have nothing to wear, reach for this and you do,” she says. “This is one of those pieces that works for any outfit.” The shirt is made from a cotton poplin that’s thin and delicate, according to writer Mya Gelber, who tried it on as part of her hunt for the perfect white button-down. It’s “something to throw over a swimsuit or for a stroll to the farmers’ market,” Gelber says. The Old Navy number comes in at just under $40 — and is often marked down — making it the cheapest button-down on this list.

Sizes: 00-24 | Fabric: Cotton poplin | Design details: Bigger patch pocket | Price: $$

I’d be remiss not to include J.Crew on this list — I’ve been buying its button-downs for close to a decade. I feel well dressed in the shirts, which are well made and well tailored from a material that feels more expensive than it is. Even as someone who’s bustier, curvier, and shorter, I find that J.Crew just gets the fit right.

Each season, there are new additions to its line of shirts — everything from embellished numbers to pin-striped options. Under the creative direction of Olympia Gayot, the brand’s signature button-downs are now called the Garçon and Étienne, which are fully stocked currently. The Garçon is slimmer and more fitted than the Étienne (something I noticed with the brand’s button-downs overall is they’re now made to fit slightly smaller, so keep that in mind while shopping and size up if you want a roomier fit). The Garçon, which is made of crisp cotton poplin, is also available in sizes 00 to 24 (plus petite and tall), one of the largest size ranges on this list.

Sizes: 0–14 | Fabric: Cotton | Design details: Long cuffs, side slits, French seams, grosgrain detailing, and pearl buttons | Price: $$$

Classic Six’s Donna Shirt is fitted, too, with extra-long cuffs designed to hit past the wrist. Style coach Kim Hancher likes the playful touch. “It’s always fun to have an interesting detail on a basic, which a white shirt is,” she says. (The Donna also has convenient buttons on the cuffs that make it easy to double them up if you want them out of your way.) Though it’s a more tailored take than the more oversize options above, it’s designed with dropped shoulders and a “torso [long enough] that it stays tucked in.” Hancher explains that she usually has to size up to get that kind of length, but “then it’s big all over, which is sometimes a look I want, sometimes not.” According to Hancher, the proportions on this shirt are pretty much perfect, with a larger collar and nipped-in waist. “It’s just a white shirt, but it adds so much to every outfit that I wear it with,” Hancher says.

Another splurge-worthy contender: styles from French label Anne Fontaine — the “master of the white shirt,” according to stylist Jessica Cadmus — which have a “trim and tailored” silhouette, with eye-catching details, like Shakespearean ruffles.

Sizes: XS–XL | Fabric: Cotton, nylon, elastane | Design: Single patch pocket, wide cuffs, and box pleat on back yoke | Price: $$

If you want a button-down that falls between fitted and oversize, you’ll want to look for one billed as “relaxed fit” (sometimes simply called “relaxed”). It’s the silhouette Gelber had in mind when she began her button-down hunt, which included trying on shirts at Alex Mill and J.Crew and placing orders at Gap and Land’s End. More than two dozen button-downs later, Gelber found a winner in Lululemon’s. Lululemon might not be the brand that comes to mind when you hear the word “button-down,” but its Relaxed-Fit Cotton-Blend Poplin Button-Down Shirt (the only one it currently sells for women) fits her strict standards. It looks just as good tucked or untucked and has a longer, bum-covering length, along with “big stiff cuffs as well as a structured collar and a back box pleat that makes it billow really beautifully,” she says. And because it’s from Lululemon, it’s lightweight, quick-drying, and sweat-wicking too.

Sizes: XXS–3X | Fabric: Cotton | Design: Single patch pocket, high-low shirttail hem | Price: $$

Up until recently, most of Anthropologie’s button-downs were under the label Cloth & Stone. But when I interviewed Anthropologie employees last year, I learned that the Bennet Buttondown from Maeve, an in-house line, is what’s hanging in stores now. The latest iteration is a hit with customers and employees alike: “They got the proportions of it really right,” a display coordinator says. A manager told me that the button-down has an oversize silhouette and recommended sizing down if you want something more fitted. I’m especially impressed with the shirt’s size inclusiveness: It comes in sizes XXS through 3X (along with a petite length). Even better: There’s an adaptive version for those who have disabilities — with magnetic snap closures, a tab on the sleeve cuffs (rather than buttons), and a higher shirttail slits (for more coverage).

I’d like to give Baserange’s “lavishly oversize” Ole Shirt an honorable mention in this category, too — Strategist writer Erin Schwartz says it’s “so crisp you could crack an egg on it.”

Sizes: XXS–XL | Fabric: Linen | Design: Looser fit, bust-flattering button placement | Price: $$$

Frank & Eileen launched in 2009 with the mission to “reinvent the button-up for women” — since then, the company has earned a loyal following. The Eileen is its No. 1 best-selling shirt, cut from an Italian linen that’s then made into a shirt in Mexico. Stylist Grace Thomas likes that the button-down is a combination of relaxed and elevated — even when wrinkled, the shirt has an air of “I just threw this on” to it without looking sloppy. “It hangs well on my body, always looks crisp, and makes me feel put-together so simply,” says Thomas. She preaches about quality over quantity to clients, and says that Frank & Eileen’s shirts are really the only button-down you’ll need. (If you prefer something other than linen, the style is also available in denim, flannel, cotton, and voile, too.)

My runner-up in this category is Aritzia’s Wilfred button-down, which is made with a blend of linen and viscose, will run you only $88, and is a favorite of Sips By founder Staci Brinkman, who likes that it doesn’t feel starchy or stiff in the slightest.

Sizes: XXS–XXL | Fabric: Silk | Design details: Concealed mother-of-pearl buttons, monogrammable (for an additional $25) | Price: $$

Since Equipment’s silk shirt is on the pricier side, I wanted to hunt down a comparable button-down that’s a lot less. Stylist Erica Ball turned me toward this one — and her recommendation is especially notable because she also owns our best overall silk pick, so she can really speak to how the two compare. This option from LilySilk is made from a lighter silk. (The company uses the mulberry kind seen in Slip’s sleeping masks, which Cora Harrington, author of In Intimate Detail: How to Choose, Wear, and Love Lingerie called out as high-quality without a high price tag.) It’s cut slightly slimmer than Equipment’s, making it more tailored to the body. And since the buttons are hidden, it resembles a tuxedo shirt, too. (You could also consider a less splurgy satiny button-down: Designer-slash-blogger Gabrielle Arruda backs a version from Zara for its “glamorous texture.” Though button-downs tend to have “business” associations to them, she points to the high-sheen style as one for evenings out or when you want your outfit to have some dramatic flair. But be warned: Zara items often sell out quickly.)