How we chose the 2024 Travel Awards winners

We don't take choosing the best of the best lightly—especially regarding travel products, which can be pricey. Our team took this testing process so seriously, in fact, that we traveled to Japan and Paris, road-tripped up and down the East Coast and even took these products on a cruise.

Related

select

selectIntroducing our 2024 Best of Travel Awards

First and foremost, our team compiled all previous coverage from NBC Select’s travel-related categories. From there, we chose products featured in our articles and did a competitive market research analysis on new and additional products, including those that are expert-recommended and highly rated. We focused particularly on products our team owns personally or has had extended time using.

When we review a product, we do so comprehensively. Products underwent an eight-week trial period before being selected as our favorites in their respective categories. We utilized our editors as shopping and trying experts. Each editor was given the same testing criteria during the testing period to ensure each item was held to the same standards and procedures. We want to provide products that perform well and share ones that allow our readers to improve their travel experience.

As part of the testing process, our editors scored items on a scale of 1 to 3. The products were evaluated, among other things, on the below criteria:

Space

• How much clothes or outfits can you pack inside of the suitcase?
• Does the bag or suitcase feel spacious or have enough pockets?

Durability

• Does the bag or suitcase sustain scratches or dents easily? 
• Is the luggage weather resistant or able to repel any water?

Handles and straps

• Are the handles able to support a fully packed bag?
• How does the suitcase handle feel on different surfaces?
• Do the straps of the luggage feel comfortable when fully packed?

Zippers 

• Does the zipper glide along smoothly or does it feel flimsy?
• Do the zippers get stuck when fully packed?

When a product carries the NBC Select badge, you can trust that our team of editors, as shopping experts, vetted the item thoroughly. We are journalists, first and foremost, which means we will always do our research and reporting.

Catch up on NBC Select’s in-depth coverage of tech and tools, wellness and more, and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and TikTok to stay up to date.