our shopping cart

The Strategist Haul: What the Editors Bought in October

Photo-Illustration: The Strategist; Photos: Retailers

Obviously, Strategist staffers are excellent shoppers (it’s why you’re here visiting the site right now). So once a month, we highlight all the things we’ve been buying for ourselves. You’ll notice that it’s both a blessing and a curse to be a Strategist editor; we’re picky, but sometimes we just have to get on with it. (It’s online-shopping expertise meets IRL needs.) Below, what we bought in October.

Ailbhe Malone, senior editor

I bought a Stutterheim Stockholm raincoat four years ago and have just never really gotten on with it. I love how it looks but loathe how it feels — and I got increasingly fed up with staying dry to my knees and soaked from my shins down. So I caved and bought this waterproof trench from Alexa Chung’s Barbour collection. It’s ankle-length, and the hood is detachable. I bought it in chocolate brown. Do I look a little like Inspector Gadget while wearing it? Maybe. But I’m into it.

I bought a giant box o’ blocks on Prime Day for my 2.5-year-old.

Kelsie Schrader, managing editor

I am on a (vaguely serious) hunt for a black sweater to replace an old H&M one that was never that nice to begin with and now looks terrible because I’ve worn it a ton. It was cropped to just the right length on my short torso and quite loose, which meant I could wear it with really anything. And the weight was great for all temperatures. I was constantly tossing it in my bag to throw over something if I got cold. I wanted to find something like it, but nicer (though still not too expensive, ideally), so I got this Banana Republic sweater while it was on sale for $28 earlier this month, and I told myself if it wasn’t exactly what I was looking for, I wouldn’t keep it because I have too many sweaters already. Well, it’s a bit longer than I’d like, and while I like its looseness, its length means it’s not quite as versatile, to me, as my old sweater was. But it is extremely soft, as its title says, and after putting it on once, I knew I wouldn’t be able to return it, especially at that price. It’s not the sweater, but it’s a good sweater, and I’ve worn it many times already.

Hilary Reid alerted us to a rare J.Crew cashmere sale and then spoke well of this particular sweater’s fit. I decided to try it, too, and again told myself: If it’s not perfect, return it. Well, guess what: It’s not exactly what I’m after (it’s tighter than what I’m looking for and, though warm and soft, a bit thinner than my old one). But guess what else: I kept it. I like its tight, shrunken fit at the bottom and slightly looser fit at the top. It’ll be easy to wear both casually and more dressed up. I regret nothing!

Amelia Jerden, sleep writer

My apartment has a washer and dryer, but they are stashed in a little closet built to the exact specifications of the machines, meaning there’s no place to keep laundry detergent and other cleaning supplies. The front-load dryer is stacked over the washer, so for the past two years, I’ve been storing all my laundry supplies on top of it. The problem was that I could barely reach them, and they frequently fell off if the dryer wobbled too much. In a bout of reorganizing, I bought this hanging basket from the Container Store. It is meant for an iron and ironing board, but instead, I used it to store all my laundry supplies and hang my drying rack, which I had previously tucked between the washer and the wall of the closet.

I bought a few different polishes from Mooncat, but my favorite so far is this multi-chrome lacquer that changes colors depending on the angle you look from. I can’t stop looking down at my hands and just watching my nails shift in different lighting.

Emma Wartzman, kitchen and dining writer

This month was dedicated to some (very light!) winter clothes shopping. Gap has been having a great sale for a few weeks now, and I snagged this cotton knit sweater in a light blue (that color is no longer available, but there are some other nice ones). It is oversize, as promised, drapes nicely, and is thick but not too hot. I have already worn it several times.

$10 for 2

I’m also in the process of a little sock refresh and bought this two-pack of ribbed pairs, which are the undisputed best length of a quarter-crew (despite the fact that the name says “ankle”). I went with the beige-and-brown combo and find them very cozy.

Winnie Yang, senior editor

If you saw me in real life or in a Zoom meeting this past month, I was probably wearing this shirt, which I bought as soon as it became available and have taken off only for washing. It’s a heavier-weight jersey and feels almost like a piqué knit; I like the extra bit of structure it has. The cornflower-and-burgundy stripe I got is now sold out, but there’s still a blue-and-white-striped version.

My 8-year-old asked to read this book aloud at bedtime earlier this month, and we all liked it so much that we gave our copy to a friend to read to her daughter and bought a few more to give as birthday presents. We also got the two companion novels, which we are making our way through now.

Rachael Griffiths, writer

$25

Well. After a summer of clear skin, my acne is back. I’m not sure if it’s stress, a new product I’ve used, or a prehistoric curse on me and my family — but I’m spotty once again. Acne can make you feel insecure anyway, but when you’re a skin-care writer, there’s the added frustration (and embarrassment, almost) that your skin is somehow evidence that you’re doing your job wrong. Instead of ripping my hair out trying to figure it out, I’m going back to the basics: a double-cleanse with an oil-based cleanser, followed by this benzoyl peroxide cleanser and lots and lots of moisture. (This is the brand I use in the U.K., but in the U.S., Paula’s Choice and CeraVe are far more affordable.)

For my slutty McLovin costume, and for my slutty Anne Boleyn costume, respectively.

Dominique Pariso, writer

Believe it or not, I didn’t do too much shopping during a ten-day trip to Italy. Marzipan, several jars of pistachio cream, a pair of yellow-and-green Friulane shoes, and a few pairs of Gammarelli socks made up the bulk of my haul. I also picked up this scented terra-cotta pomegranate from Santa Maria Novella. Could I have picked this up at the New York store? Absolutely. Would I have dropped $75 on it if I weren’t already on vacation? Probably not. But I am delighted by it. I popped it on my nightstand when I returned home and swear I’ve been sleeping better now that my bed is lightly perfumed.

Jenna Milliner-Waddell, associate editor

I moved into my new apartment back in May, and it’s been a slow process of getting it together. My latest purchase was two of these Zara lamps for my bedside. I had my eye on them for a while but was hesitant to spend a total of $300 on them. When a pair popped up on Facebook Marketplace for $175, I jumped on it. It was a bit impulsive, considering I still don’t have essentials like barstools or nightstands to even sit them on, but I couldn’t let this deal pass.

This Gap jacket has been saved on my Pinterest for about a month now, but it sold out pretty quickly. I was poking around for alternatives when I was served an ad for the Gap Factory version. The hairs on this one are a bit shorter and there’s no elasticized hem, but I thought it still might give me the look I was going for. It just arrived, and I think it looks even more similar to the Frame jacket and this one from A.L.C. than even the OG Gap jacket. And for just $48 (I bought it during the Friends and Family sale), I think I’ll take it to a tailor and get my own elastic waist put in.

Ambar Pardilla, writer

I ordered a lot of long-sleeved tees this month in the hopes of finding another favorite. This is the winner. It’s loose, but not too loose. It’s cheapish without feeling cheapish. It can be layered or left on its own. I’ll probably buy one in every color by next month.

I have a sweet tooth, and it’s a small miracle I don’t have rows of rotten teeth. I stockpiled boxes of Pocky sticks — these strawberry ones, but also the chocolate and matcha — after an impulsive grocery-store run. I’m hoping my dentist won’t say the word cavity at my next appointment.

Hilary Reid, senior editor

I was hunting for a pair of comfortable-ish, low-ish, affordable-ish heels to wear to a couple of weddings in November, and that search took me straight to the & Other Stories at the Oculus (which tends to be quieter and better stocked than its other stores in the city, I’ve found!). There was a patent pair that I had in mind, but when I saw these, which are made of an almost grosgrain-like material, I was sold. I broke them in by wearing them to the opera recently, and so far, they’re indeed pretty comfortable. The true test will be the dance floor.

It’s finally getting colder, which also means my skin is getting drier, so I decided to try CosRX’s Snail Mucin. I feel about seven years late to the party — since Rio first wrote about this stuff in her 2017 skin-care doc — but it’s still consistently a Strat reader favorite, so I’m excited to see if I love it as much as everyone else seems to.

Liza Corsillo, senior writer

My husband discovered this board book at the toddler-friendly Airbnb we stayed in for a friend’s wedding last month. And after giggling at the ’70s-esque illustrations with him, I decided to buy a copy for us and one for a friend who is expecting. The story follows Ned as he is flung between fortunate and unfortunate events. “Fortunately, a friend loaned Ned an airplane. Unfortunately, the motor exploded,” is just the beginning of his journey. The fortunate pages are illustrated in full color, and the unfortunate ones are in black-and-white.

Somewhat related: My almost 2-year-old son has been getting more and more confident on the playground. Unfortunately, this means he is bumping his head and knees a lot. And because he’s freaked out by a bag of frozen peas as an ice pack, and the idea of ice packs altogether, we bought these friendly packs that come with adorable fuzzy covers. So far, they’re a hit.

Crystal Martin, senior editor

Over the past few years, I’ve become a nice-pajamas person. Once I tried one pair of Bed Head PJs, it was only a week before I bought another set. The cotton is crisp and cool (a necessity for my especially toasty, radiator-heated bedroom) and yet still feels cozy because of the substantial weight of the fabric. Plus, the prints are super cute.

I took the plunge and limewashed my bedroom. After much research, I went with Color Atelier paint because I’d heard from a pro painter it was easy to work with for DIYers and had the best color selection and great coverage. I’d read a lot of scary-sounding DIY stories, mostly about how limewash is impossibly hard and the result might be a hot mess and, if so, very difficult to fix. Not my experience at all. It’s labor intensive (must be applied with a thick brush by hand), but it’s not something that requires specific skills per se. My tips: Cut in the edges first, the cloud application technique is a must, and leave a couple of days for the project. The velvety-looking walls are so worth it.

Lauren Ro, writer

I bought my first pair of B Sides (the Plein style in black) nearly five years ago (when they were going for under $150), and they’re the jeans I wear the most. They’re a relaxed, straight-fit style with a wider leg and high rise and are made with heavyweight denim. This month, I sprung for another pair, the Slim Lasso, a barrel-leg jean (the brand calls it a “kinked leg”) that might supplant my Pleins as the heroes of my wardrobe. They’re made of a “classic weight” denim in a nice blue wash and are constructed with panels on the outer sides that give the pants their structured look. They’re probably the best-fitting jeans I own. (For reference, I’m five-foot-two and have a short torso and wide hips.) Compared to the Plein, the Slim Lassos sit lower on the waist with a more relaxed hip and just hug me everywhere. And they’re the perfect length. (The Pleins, which are more fitted in the hips, give me a big waist gap. I sized down with the Lassos.) B Sides’ jeans have gotten more expensive over the years, but they’re extremely well made — in the U.S., to boot — and will last forever. (Sizing is limited on the B Sides website, so check other retailers like Shopbop, where I bought mine.)

Bella Druckman, junior writer

Gap’s 40 percent off Friends and Family sale endured for nine whole days and was enough time for me to visit the store twice (which is more times than I can say I’ve been in there since I was in high school). Though I’ve been wearing most of the items I purchased on repeat, I’m particularly excited about these baggy cargo pants, which look just as good with a tucked-in collared shirt as they do with a hoodie.

I became intrigued by East Fork’s Everyday Bowl after reading about it in our guide to bowls, so I took its recent Seconds Sale as an excuse to get myself the bowl and support the brand whose Asheville studio was badly affected by Hurricane Helene. The bowl just arrived this week, and I’m already impressed by its shape, which is the perfect balance between wide and stout.

Jen Trolio, senior editor

I coach U10 girls’ soccer, and someone is pretty much always asking around for a ball pump at practices and games. This October Prime Day purchase is my new favorite doodad: There’s no guesswork because it stops automatically once the ball is inflated to a preset PSI, it comes with two needles that dock right into the side, and it’s rechargeable, too.

Another year, another LEGO City Advent Calendar!

[Note: This year’s LEGO City Advent Calendar is currently sold out, but you can find more in-stock Advent calendars here.]

Jeremy Rellosa, writer

I’m always burning some type of candle at my apartment, but I wanted to change it up and go for some hinoki incense. My local gift shop had these in stock, and I have been burning it nonstop this month. The cones burn for about ten minutes and fill up the room quickly but aren’t overpowering. They have a calming, clean woody scent.

I like running and working out in cotton tees even though they don’t wick sweat or breathe as well as some tech tees. There’s something nice about the way sweat marks my cotton shirts during a run — almost like it’s a sign I’m working hard. One of my favorite shirts to run in is the brand’s Grayboy tee, so I got this one for winter training. It’s lighter and softer than the Grayboy. It’s also nice knowing that all proceeds from this shirt go toward the Tracksmith Foundation, which helps give more people the opportunity to participate in the sport.

Sam Daly, deals writer

Bottoms is a perfect movie, so obviously, I had to have a watch party with my little sister when I found out she hadn’t seen it yet. We laughed, we cried, and we concluded that Ayo Edebiri and Rachel Sennott deserve Golden Globes immediately. So when I saw this picture of Ayo wearing this tee, I had to buy it for my sister for her birthday. It’s also just a sentiment that fits her perfectly.

Kitty Guo, writer

I bought these Maggie’s Organics socks right after I read Strategist contributor Ruby Redstone’s ode to them, and I brought them with me when I went home for the holidays last winter. My mom came into my room while I was folding laundry and took a real shine to them — “thick and high-quality,” she’d called them. Her birthday is coming up soon, so I bought her six pairs: a three-pack of the natural ivory and a three-pack of the denim/eggplant/navy colors.

I’d been on the hunt for a plain black belt for a while now and finally picked up this Gap one from a thrift store upstate. It was about one size too big for me, but I figured I could just create a new hole in the leather with a hammer and nail — easy enough, right? In actuality, it took about an hour of scraping, whittling, and nearly giving myself tetanus in the process to finally make a hole wide enough for the buckle to pass through. Lesson learned!

Brenley Goertzen, junior writer

I bought this plush monkey from a local dog store called Bone & Biscuit for our basset hound puppy, Ringo. He’s in the teething stage, and the monkey’s arms and legs crinkle, keeping him occupied for hours. It’s less obnoxious compared to other squeaky toys we own — and looks pretty cute when he carries it around!

The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

The Strategist Haul: What the Editors Bought in October